Menu

Breakfast

Summertime Blues

Summertime Blues

Frosty’s breakfast is legendary on the island and around the Great Lakes. Served from 7AM-11AM, Frosty’s has something for everyone. Favorites include the Country Benedict, Blueberry Pancakes, and the infamous Eggs Benedict. Don’t forget to check out the daily specials- Chili, Cheese, and Eggs is a weekend favorite.

Due to the immense popularity, there’s usually a short line for breakfast. Don’t let the line discourage you, as we serve the best breakfast on the island- just ask someone already in line. You can also grab a cup of Joe while you wait, or try one of our breakfast cocktails like a Bloody Mary or a Frosty Orange. Both are quite tasty and will relieve the effects of Friday night’s frivolity.

Breakfast Menu

Lunch & Dinner

Pepperoni Pizza

Pepperoni Pizza

Frosty Pizza is legendary throughout the region, but it is not all we have to offer our hungry customers. After Breakfast has ended, the Pizza crew arrives to fire up the ovens.

In addition to our savory, made-to-order pizzas, Frosty’s also has a selection of specialty pizzas, submarine sandwiches and grinders.

Put-in-Bay is a popular destination for school groups, reunions and gatherings. If you would like to have Frosty’s supply lunch or dinner for your group, give us a call. Arrangements can be made for you to dine-in or carryout.

Lunch and Dinner Menu

Big Man’s Burrito Stand

The Big Man’s Burrito Stand has quick serve food made with fresh produce and homemade salsa.

Big Man’s Burrito Stand Menu

The Backyard

The Backyard at Frosty’s Bar is a fun outdoor venue which serves fresh fruit margaritas, specialty cocktails and offers entertainment under the stars.

The Backyard Menu