Skip Navigation

Welcome to Frosty Bar and Family Pizza on Put-in-Bay, Ohio!

Frosty Bar on beautiful Put-in-Bay, Ohio

Located in the heart of Put-in-Bay’s downtown, Frosty’s has been proud to serve island visitors and locals for over 50 years. Whether you’re hungry for a pizza, thirsty for a cold beer, or looking for the best breakfast on Put-in-Bay, Frosty’s is a great place to gather, socialize, and enjoy the island atmosphere.

Overlooking historic DeRivera Park and Put-in-Bay Harbor, Frosty’s offers a stunning view of downtown Put-in-Bay. Come in for breakfast, lunch, or dinner and enjoy the two Valley pool tables, video games, and new hits and old tavern favorites on the juke box. Watch your favorite team on our plasma screen TV’s.

Click on the Calendar page to view upcoming events at Frostys and our Spring business hours!

Frosty's Talk of the Tavern

Queen Victoria Day - An Island Tradition

Victoria Day marks the beginning of the season at Put-in-Bay. A Canadian holiday, Queen Victoria Day is celebrated on the last Monday before or on May 24 in honour of both Queen Victoria’s birthday and the current reigning Canadian sovereign’s birthday. Along with Canada, some parts of Scotland and the Cayman Islands, the Lake Erie islands celebrate the holiday which precedes Memorial Day weekend in the Spring.

Events featured on Victoria Day include:

  • Downtown Scavenger Hunt: 1-3 PM

  • Put-in-Bay Poker Run: 4-6 PM

  • Island-Wide Garage Sale: 10 AM - 5 PM

Downtown Scavenger Hunt and Put-in-Bay Poker Run

Entry is only $15 and participants can enter more than once. Sign up will be located in De Rivera Park (across from Frosty’s). Prizes include mini-island vacation packages consisting of island lodging, meals, ferry and island transportation as well as souvenirs for 2 people! Many more prizes will be given away throughout the day. Come join the fun!

Island-Wide Garage Sale

What better way than to get started on some Spring cleaning that by donating your unwanted items for the 5th Annual Island-Wide Garage Sale?! Sponsored by the Put-in-Bay Chamber of Commerce, all proceeds will go to help support the chamber in its mission to promote community and visitor activities on the island. Get listed in the garage sale map FREE by calling June Stoiber at 419.285.4741 by Monday, May 12th.